VILLA KUNALAI PUBLIC COMPANY LIMITEDSET: KUN🇹🇭 TH

Internal Control · 2025

Internal Control — Board Opinion

Summary of the Board's Opinion on Internal Control

The Board of Directors of Villa Kunalai Public Company Limited has considered and evaluated the adequacy and effectiveness of the company's internal control system for the year ended December 31, 2025, covering all five key components in accordance with the framework of The Committee of Sponsoring Organizations of the Treadway Commission (COSO), namely Control Environment, Risk Assessment, Control Activities, Information and Communication, and Monitoring Activities.

Based on the review of reports from the management, the internal audit department, and the Audit Committee, the Board of Directors is of the opinion that the Company possesses an adequate, appropriate, and effective internal control system to support business operations in achieving defined objectives. This includes managing significant risks to an acceptable level, ensuring strict compliance with laws, regulations, and the Company's policies, as well as maintaining the reliability of financial reports and ensuring accurate, transparent, and timely disclosure of information.

Furthermore, the Company has established appropriate segregation of duties, clearly defined approval authorities, and a continuous monitoring system. The internal audit department has conducted audits according to the approved plan and regularly reported the results to the Audit Committee, to ensure that the internal control system remains effective and is continuously improved.

The Board of Directors did not identify any significant deficiencies in the Company's internal control system for the year 2025. Nevertheless, the Company is committed to continuously developing and enhancing its internal control system to align with the evolving business environment and support the organization's long-term sustainable growth.

Adequacy & Appropriateness of the Internal Control System

Internal Control Framework Used

FrameworkDetail
The Committee of Sponsoring Organizations of the Treadway Commission (COSO)

Villa Kunalai Public Company Limited places importance on establishing effective, comprehensive, and good corporate governance-compliant internal control systems. The Company has adopted the framework of The Committee of Sponsoring Organizations of the Treadway Commission (COSO) as a guideline for designing and developing its internal control systems to support business operations efficiently, transparently, accountably, and with appropriate risk management.

The Company has implemented internal controls covering the following five key components:

1. Control Environment

The Company establishes a clear governance structure, with the Board of Directors, Audit Committee, and management having appropriate roles and responsibilities in overseeing and monitoring operations. It also sets policies, business ethics, and various guidelines to promote an organizational culture of transparency, accountability, and anti-corruption.

2. Risk Assessment

The Company identifies, analyzes, and assesses risks that may impact the achievement of organizational objectives at both the corporate and operational levels, linking them to the Enterprise Risk Management (ERM) framework and defining acceptable risk appetite to serve as a systematic guideline for risk management.

3. Control Activities

The Company establishes appropriate control measures, such as Segregation of Duties, authorization limits for transactions, development of operational procedures, and control over access to information and assets, to prevent and reduce risks arising from errors or fraud.

4. Information and Communication Systems

The Company has information systems that support operations and the reporting of accurate, complete, and timely data, along with appropriate internal and external communication channels, including transparent disclosure of information to shareholders and stakeholders in accordance with regulatory guidelines.

5. Monitoring Activities

The Company continuously monitors and evaluates the effectiveness of its internal control systems. The internal audit unit is responsible for regularly auditing and reporting findings to the Audit Committee, and internal control systems are adjusted to align with changing risks and business environments.

Overall, the Company has internal control systems that are adequate, appropriate, and effective in supporting business operations to achieve strategic objectives, reduce operational risks, and build confidence among shareholders and stakeholders, which is a crucial foundation for the organization's sustainable growth.

Internal Control Deficiencies

Number of Deficiencies

MetricCurrent YearPrevious YearTwo Years Ago
Total number of internal control system deficiencies (cases)0011

Deficiency Details

Period TypeStart Period (YYYY-MM)End Period (YYYY-MM)DetailProgress StatusCorrective Action
month/year Range2023-062023-08
Human Resources Control: An examination of employee leave data via the E-Leave system during June – August 2023, comprising 14 entries, revealed the following: - 4 entries of leave did not comply with policies and operational procedures. - 7 entries had inconsistencies between the stated leave type and the reason for leave. The primary causes were operational errors by employees (Human Error) and inconsistent understanding of leave regulations. This could lead to ineffective enforcement of human resource policies and pose a risk of improper management of absences.
Incident no longer subject to action

The company has improved and enhanced internal controls regarding the aforementioned issues as follows:

  • Communicate and clarify the company's leave policies, criteria, and procedures to all employees.

  • Emphasize to employees and supervisors the strict adherence to regulations.

  • Increase supervision and verification of data accuracy in the system by supervisors.

  • Continuously monitor and review operations to prevent similar errors from occurring in the future.

month/year Range2023-012023-03
Information Security Policy An assessment of the information security management (IT Security Policy) revealed that the Company has not yet formally established and implemented an information security policy. Additionally, there are no clear guidelines covering information technology controls. Consequently, data access control, user privilege assignment, and IT risk management may be inadequate in scope and lack systematic implementation, potentially failing to adequately mitigate data security risks.
Incident no longer subject to action

The Company has improved and upgraded information security controls to align with relevant information technology risks. Details are as follows:

  • Developed and implemented an Information Security Policy (IT Security Policy) to establish a systematic framework for the organization's information security management.

  • Developed an Information Security Plan (IT Security Plan: ISP) to cover information technology risks, including operational security measures.

  • Mandated policy endorsement by management and communicated it to relevant employees for strict awareness and compliance.

  • Mandated the review and update of the information security policy and plan at least once a year to align with evolving operations and risk situations.

  • Continuously monitor and evaluate policy compliance to ensure that information technology control systems are appropriate and effective.

month/year Range2023-012023-03
Asset Management: An inspection of 10 client machines revealed that the information in the hardware and software asset register was inconsistent with the actual assets in use, specifically regarding asset holder information, asset details, and usage status. Such discrepancies may result in ineffective control and monitoring of organizational assets, increasing the risk of asset loss, and potentially hindering the efficient conduct of information technology maintenance and troubleshooting. Furthermore, the lack of regular review of licensed software usage may pose a risk of unlawful software usage, which could impact the company's reputation and legal risks.
Incident no longer subject to action

The Company has implemented improvements to its IT asset management processes as follows:

  • Reviewed and updated Hardware and Software asset registers to ensure they are current, specifying key details such as asset number, asset name, specifications, installation location, and user/custodian.

  • Mandated periodic verification and reconciliation of asset data with actual usage to ensure data accuracy and completeness.

  • Established control processes for asset possession and changes to ensure proper recording and approval.

  • Reviewed and controlled software usage to comply with license terms, thereby mitigating legal and reputational risks for the organization.

  • Assigned the Information Technology (IT) department responsibility for continuous monitoring and management of assets.

month/year Range2023-012023-03
Access Control An audit of information system access controls revealed that the company has clearly defined password security policies, such as specifying username formats, requiring complex passwords of at least 8 characters, and mandating password changes every 90 days. However, a review of actual operations indicated that the access control settings for the Business Plus system do not align with the established policies, and no concrete evidence of the implementation or enforcement of these measures was found. This deficiency may lead to ineffective system access control and increase the risk of unauthorized access to data or systems, potentially compromising the organization's data security.
Incident no longer subject to action

The Company has implemented enhancements to information system access control as follows:

  • Reviewed and updated information technology system security policies regarding password settings to align with security best practices and standards.

  • Established appropriate and secure password formats, e.g., comprising lowercase letters, uppercase letters, numbers, and special characters, as well as setting a minimum password length.

  • Mandated initial password changes upon system access and established appropriate password change intervals.

  • Configured the system (System Configuration) in accordance with established policies and ensured enforceability.

  • Implemented logging and tracking of user password change history for retrospective auditing.

  • Communicated policies and guidelines to employees and continuously monitored compliance, with IT and HR departments jointly responsible.

month/year Range2023-012023-03
Physical and Environmental Security An inspection of IT equipment maintenance revealed that the company performs preventive maintenance for server computers appropriately. However, there is no systematic evidence of preventive maintenance for client computers, such as equipment cleaning, inspection of power cables, signal cables, and the environmental conditions of the installation sites. This deficiency may result in some IT equipment being in an unsuitable operational condition or deteriorating prematurely, as well as increasing the risk of technical issues and unavailability of information systems.
Incident no longer subject to action

The Company has implemented improvements to its physical and environmental security control processes as follows:

  • Established a Preventive Maintenance Plan for all computer and peripheral equipment, with clearly defined maintenance cycles (at least 1–2 times per year).

  • Mandated maintenance for client devices, covering equipment cleaning, inspection of power cables, signal cables, and the environmental conditions of the installation site.

  • Incorporated guidelines and maintenance plans into the Physical Security Policy to ensure systematic implementation.

  • Developed Work Instructions (WI) for the maintenance of information technology equipment to standardize operational procedures.

  • Assigned the Information Technology (IT) department responsibility for monitoring and consistently performing maintenance, and for retaining operational evidence for auditing purposes.

month/year Range2023-012023-01
Operations Security A review of operations security revealed the following observations: (1) The company has not formally established an Operations Security policy. This results in a potential lack of clarity and appropriate standards for defining information system usage guidelines. (2) Although the company has partially developed and tested data recovery (restore) plans, these plans do not yet cover critical information systems such as Business Plus, Active Directory, and File Sharing systems. Consequently, in the event of an emergency, the existing plans may not be able to provide effective support. (3) The company has not concretely established a Disaster Recovery Site (DR Site). Furthermore, systematic testing of system functionality on backup machines has not been observed. This could increase the risk of system disruption and loss of critical data in the event of an emergency. These deficiencies may impact business continuity and the efficiency of IT incident management.
Incident no longer subject to action

The Company has implemented improvements to its Operational Security control systems as follows:

  • Developed and implemented an Information Security Policy covering Operational Security aspects to establish guidelines and standards for the use of the organization's information systems.

  • Ensured communication of policies to relevant employees to raise awareness and enable correct implementation.

  • Developed and conducted tests for Data Restore plans to cover critical information systems such as the Business Plus system, Active Directory system, and File Sharing system.

  • Mandated testing of Full System Restore plans at least 1–2 times per year and reporting test results to management.

  • Established guidelines for emergency response, allowing system usage via backup clients, and regularly tested the system's functionality on backup clients.

  • Continuously monitored and reviewed security measures to align with risks and evolving technological environments.

month/year Range2023-012023-03
Communications Security From the communications security audit, the following observations were found: (1) The company does not have a formal policy or procedure regarding employee email usage, nor does it have clear control guidelines and penalties. This may increase the risk of threats from unsolicited emails or phishing emails. (2) The company stores Internet usage logs for its main system completely as required by law. However, it does not cover the storage of logs for the backup internet system (NT), resulting in incomplete data storage according to the Computer-Related Crime Act B.E. 2560 (2017). These deficiencies may expose the company to information security risks and legal risks in cases where complete system usage evidence cannot be audited or stored.
Incident no longer subject to action

The Company has enhanced data communication security controls as follows:

  • Develop and implement an Email Usage Policy, specifying appropriate usage guidelines, security measures, and penalties for non-compliance.

  • Communicate policies and raise employee awareness regarding email-related risks, such as phishing emails, and prevention guidelines.

  • Improve the process for storing Internet usage history (Internet Log) to cover all connection channels, including the backup internet system (NT), in compliance with legal requirements.

  • Establish regular inspection and monitoring of Log storage to ensure that data is fully stored for the legally mandated period (not less than 90 days).

  • Continuously review and update information security policies to align with relevant risks and legal requirements.

month/year Range2023-012023-03
Supplier relationships Upon reviewing the management of external service providers, it was found that the company communicates issues and tracks system resolutions via email to external service providers (Vendors) for relevant systems, such as the Mango system and the Internet system. Issue notifications are documented. However, there is no systematic overall report on issues and resolutions from external service providers, or at least once a year. This deficiency may result in incomplete monitoring, verification, and evaluation of external service provider performance, potentially impacting the continuity and operational efficiency of the organization.
Incident no longer subject to action

The Company has implemented enhancements to the control over the management of external service providers, as follows:

  • Established systematic guidelines and processes for coordination, problem reporting, and tracking resolution outcomes from external service providers.

  • Ensured the comprehensive recording and storage of incident logs and resolution outcomes from external service providers.

  • Prepared summary reports on issues and service performance of external service providers at least once a year, to be presented to management for consideration and improvement of service efficiency.

  • Mandated regular monitoring and evaluation of the services provided by external service providers to ensure that the services comply with agreements and are efficient.

  • Assigned the Information Technology (IT) department to be responsible for continuously overseeing and monitoring the operations of external service providers.

month/year Range2023-012023-03
Information Security Incident Management Upon reviewing the information technology incident management, it was found that the company has established a problem reporting process, where employees can report incidents via a form, and approval is considered by supervisors according to hierarchical levels, with problem reporting data systematically recorded. However, there is no comprehensive and periodic summary report of the incidents that have occurred, nor has this information been presented to management for use in analyzing root causes and establishing long-term preventive measures. Such deficiencies may result in the company being unable to utilize incident data for risk prevention planning, system development, or efficient improvement of operational processes.
Incident no longer subject to action

The Company has enhanced its controls for information security incident management as follows:

  • Ensure the systematic and comprehensive recording and storage of incident logs.

  • Prepare regular comprehensive reports on information technology incidents to analyze the causes, trends, and impacts of the issues.

  • Mandate periodic reporting of incident analysis results to management to support decision-making and long-term system improvements.

  • Utilize the analysis results to define preventive measures, improve systems, and develop operational processes.

  • Communicate and educate users regarding system usage guidelines and basic troubleshooting to mitigate recurring incidents.

  • The Information Technology (IT) department is assigned the responsibility of continuously monitoring, analyzing, and improving processes.

month/year Range2023-012023-03
Information management for business continuity (Information security aspects of business continuity management) Upon reviewing the IT business continuity management, the following observations were made: (1) The company has conducted an IT risk assessment. However, this assessment does not cover all information systems, and there is no systematic analysis and prioritization of risks (Risk Prioritization) to guide the establishment of appropriate risk management approaches. (2) The company has developed a manual for disaster emergency situations. However, it does not fully align with IT risks, as it has not been systematically linked to the results of the risk assessment. Furthermore, there is no evidence of plan testing in scenarios closely resembling actual events. These deficiencies may result in the company being unable to fully assess the impact of events that could disrupt IT systems and could affect business continuity in the event of an emergency.
Incident no longer subject to action

The Company has enhanced its Business Continuity Management controls as follows:

  • Conduct an Information Technology Risk Assessment (IT Risk Assessment) to cover all critical information systems of the organization.

  • Analyze and prioritize risks (Risk Prioritization) to determine appropriate risk management measures.

  • Review and update the disaster recovery / emergency response manual (Disaster Recovery / Business Continuity Plan) to align with the results of the risk assessment and cover critical business processes.

  • Mandate regular testing of the plan in simulated scenarios (Simulation / Drill) to ensure its practical applicability during an incident.

  • Communicate and disseminate the plan to relevant employees and raise awareness for compliance.

  • Continuously monitor, review, and update the plan to align with evolving risks and business environments.

month/year Range2023-012023-03
ComplianceFrom the compliance review of information technology management, the following observations were noted:(1) The Company has developed information technology policies and plans, such as a long-term IT plan and an information security policy. However, these policies do not yet cover all aspects of information security, and formal approval and promulgation by management have not been observed.(2) The Company has established a process for reporting information technology system issues. However, a comprehensive summary report of issues and root cause analysis for presentation to management and long-term system improvement has not been observed.(3) The Company has developed a disaster recovery manual. However, this manual does not fully align with information technology risks, and no testing of the plan in simulated scenarios has been observed.(4) The Company collects internet usage data for its primary systems in accordance with legal requirements. However, the collection of data for the backup internet system (NT) is not fully compliant with the legally mandated retention period.These deficiencies may result in information technology governance not being comprehensive across all dimensions, including policy, operations, risk management, and compliance with relevant laws.
Incident no longer subject to action

The Company has implemented enhancements to IT Governance and Compliance controls as follows:

  • Review and update the Information Security Policy (IT Security Policy) and related plans to cover all aspects of risk, and ensure they are officially approved and promulgated by management.

  • Arrange for policies to be reviewed and updated at least once a year to align with changing operations and risks.

  • Ensure the recording, analysis, and overall summary of IT incidents, with periodic reports to management for system improvement and future problem prevention.

  • Review and update the Business Continuity / Disaster Recovery Plan to align with risk assessment results, and ensure regular testing of the plan in simulated scenarios.

  • Improve the process of collecting internet usage data (Internet Log) to cover all systems, including the backup internet system (NT), in accordance with legal requirements.

  • Establish continuous monitoring, inspection, and evaluation of IT operations to ensure that internal controls are appropriate and effective.

Audit Committee & Auditor Observations

Audit Committee's Opinion Differs from the Board's

No

Auditor Has Observations on Internal Control

No

Opinion on the Head of Internal Audit

Head of Internal Audit

3160

Audit Committee's Opinion on the Head of Internal Audit

The Audit Committee of Villa Kunalai Public Company Limited has considered the qualifications, knowledge, abilities, experience, and independence in performing duties of the Head of Internal Audit and is of the opinion that the Head of Internal Audit is suitably qualified for the position. They possess a thorough understanding of internal audit work, risk management, and internal control systems, and can perform their duties independently, impartially, and in accordance with relevant professional standards.

Furthermore, the Audit Committee believes that the Head of Internal Audit can directly report audit results, observations, and recommendations beneficial for improving the company's operational processes and internal control systems. Regular direct reporting to the Audit Committee supports the company in having a good corporate governance system, transparency, and adherence to the principles of risk management and good corporate governance as guided by the Stock Exchange of Thailand.

The Audit Committee deems it appropriate for the Head of Internal Audit to continue in their position and supports continuous professional development to enhance the efficiency of internal audit work in line with international standards and the long-term growth of the organization.

Appointment, Discharge & Transfer of the Head of Internal Audit

Requires Audit Committee Approval

Yes

Description

Villa Kunalai Public Company Limited stipulates that the appointment, removal, and relocation of the Head of Internal Audit must adhere to good corporate governance principles. The Audit Committee plays a crucial role in considering and providing opinions to ensure the independence and effectiveness of the duties, as follows:

Appointment of the Head of Internal Audit

The Company stipulates that the appointment of the Head of Internal Audit must involve a selection process from individuals with appropriate qualifications, knowledge, abilities, and experience in internal audit, risk management, and internal control systems. The Audit Committee will assess the suitability of the nominated candidate and provide its opinion to the Board of Directors for formal approval of the appointment.

Removal of the Head of Internal Audit

The removal of the Head of Internal Audit must be based on reasonable grounds and conducted with transparency, fairness, and consideration for the independence of their duties. The Audit Committee will consider the reasons and necessity for the removal, and provide its opinion to the Board of Directors before approval, to ensure that such action does not affect the independence of the internal audit function.

Relocation of the Head of Internal Audit

In the event of a relocation or change in position of the Head of Internal Audit, the Company requires approval from the Audit Committee before submitting it to the Board of Directors for consideration and approval. This is to maintain operational continuity and preserve the independence of the internal audit function.

The Company places importance on ensuring that the internal audit function can operate independently, report directly to the Audit Committee, and have sufficient access to necessary information. This is to support the Company's internal control system, risk management, and corporate governance to be efficient, transparent, and in line with the regulations of the Stock Exchange of Thailand and international ESG best practices.

Related Party Transactions

Has Related Party Transactions

No

Counterparties & Transactions

Counterparties with Potential Conflicts

NamePerson / Juristic PersonType of BusinessNature of RelationshipAs of Date (YYYY-MM-DD)
COMFROM COMPANY LIMITEDJuristic PersonManufacturer, designer, distributor, and printer of continuous paper forms, continuous labels, business printing materials, newspapers, magazines, calendars, and other related printed products.

The Company has a related party, Mr. Khuna Dheva-aksorn, who is a director of Comform Co., Ltd. This relationship may give rise to a potential conflict of interest.

2025-12-31T00:00
WHITE DECENT COMPANY LIMITEDJuristic PersonEngaged in construction services for buildings, including residential buildings, office premises, and other non-residential structures.

The Company has a related party, Mr. Pakorn Sangkawanich, who serves as a director and holds a 51% equity interest in White Decent Co., Ltd. He is also the father of Ms. Praweerat Dheva-aksorn and Mr. Paisan Sangkawanich. Such relationships may give rise to potential conflicts of interest.

2025-12-31T00:00
AKSORN SOMBAT COMPANY LIMITEDJuristic PersonEngaged in the leasing of real estate and other activities related to properties owned or leased by the Company, excluding those for residential purposes.

The Company has a related party,

1. Mr. Khuna Dheva-aksorn, who serves as a director , major shareholder and holds a 10.375% equity interest in Aksorn Sombat Co., Ltd. This relationship may give rise to potential conflicts of interest.

  1. Mr. Pete Dheva-aksorn, who serves as a director and holds a 10.375% equity interest in Aksorn Sombat Co., Ltd. This relationship may give rise to potential conflicts of interest.

2025-12-31T00:00
LHL International Investments Company Limited.Juristic PersonInvestment / Financial Services

The Company has identified an individual who may have a potential conflict of interest, namely

  1. Mr. Khuna Dheva-aksorn, who serves as a director , major shareholder and holds a 10.375% equity interest in Aksorn Sombat Co., Ltd. This relationship may give rise to potential conflicts of interest.

  1. Mr. Pete Dheva-aksorn, who serves as a director and holds a 10.375% equity interest in Aksorn Sombat Co., Ltd. This relationship may give rise to potential conflicts of interest.

2025-12-31T00:00
Miss Panida Dheva-aksornPerson

She is a shareholder of the Company, holding 0.427 percent of the total issued shares, and is the younger sister of Mr. Khuna Dheva-aksorn.

2025-12-31T00:00
Mrs. Praweerat Dheva-aksornPerson

She serves as a Director, Risk Management Committee Member, Executive Director, and Chief Executive Officer of the Company, and is also a shareholder, holding 9.465 percent of the total issued shares. She is the spouse of Mr. Khuna Dheva-aksorn.

2025-12-31T00:00
Mr. Khuna Dheva-aksornPerson

He serves as a Director, Risk Management Committee Member, Nomination and Remuneration Committee Member, and Chairman of the Executive Committee of the Company, and is also a shareholder, holding 10.525 percent of the total issued shares. He is the spouse of Mrs. Praweerat Dheva-aksorn.

2025-12-31T00:00
R.M. PROPERTY COMPANY LIMITEDJuristic PersonEngaged in the business of buying and selling its own non-residential real estate.

As at the date of the Extraordinary General Meeting of Shareholders No. 1/2021, R.M. Property Co., Ltd. had R.M. Holding Co., Ltd. as a shareholder holding 34.293% of its shares.

R.M. Holding Co., Ltd. has the following shareholding structure:

  • Mr. Pakorn Sangkawanich holds 40% of the shares

  • Mrs. Aree Sangkawanich holds 30% of the shares

  1. Mr. Pakorn Sangkawanich and Mrs. Aree Sangkawanich are authorized directors of the company. (Mr. Pakorn Sangkawanich is the father and Mrs. Aree Sangkawanich is the mother of Ms. Praweerat Dheva-aksorn.)

In addition,

  • Ms. Praweerat Dheva-aksorn holds 5% of the shares in R.M. Holding Co., Ltd.

  • Mr. Paisan Sangkawanich holds 5% of the shares in R.M. Holding Co., Ltd.

2023-12-31T00:00
BAANCHOMPOO COMPANY LIMITEDJuristic PersonEngaged in the business of leasing and operating own or leased non-residential real estate.

The Company has a person who may have a conflict of interest, namely Ms. Praweerat Dheva-aksorn, who is a director and holds 99.99% of the shares in Baan Chompoo Co., Ltd.

The remaining shares (0.003333% each) are held by:

  • Mr. Khuna Dheva-aksorn (spouse)

  • Ms. Miriam Dheva-aksorn (adult child)

  • Mr. Ryu Dheva-aksorn (adult child)

  • Miss Pawana Dheva-aksorn (minor child)

2023-12-31T00:00
Contents